Dicing Dangers

Dice Maths

How much luck is in 4d6 drop the lowest

Rolling four six-sided dice and discarding the lowest one raises the average by about 1.7 points and thins the bottom of the range far more than the top. Every total is counted below, all 1,296 rolls.

“Roll four six-sided dice, drop the lowest, add the rest” is a common way to generate character scores, and it is usually explained with a shrug: it makes characters slightly better. The shrug hides a change in shape, and the change is not even. The bottom of the range thins out sharply, while the top gains weight.

This note counts the rolls.

The instruction, slowly

The free rules for the 2024 core rulebook describe the method as rolling four six-sided dice and recording the total of the three highest, then repeating until you have six numbers (D&D Beyond — Free Rules: Creating a Character). Different books abbreviate this differently, so this note uses the plain description: roll four dice, set the lowest aside, add the other three. If two dice tie for lowest, it does not matter which one is set aside, because the kept total is the same.

There are 6 × 6 × 6 × 6 = 1,296 ordered ways for four dice to land. Each one produces exactly one kept total between 3 and 18. Nothing here is simulated: the figures come from listing all 1,296 outcomes and counting.

Counting the corners by hand

The easiest totals can be counted without a computer, and they are a good check on the table further down.

  • Kept total 3. The three highest dice must sum to 3, so all three are 1s, and the fourth die cannot be lower than a 1. All four dice show 1: 1 way, 1/1,296, about 0.08%.
  • Kept total 4. The three highest dice are 1, 1 and 2, and the fourth die must be 1 (anything higher would be kept instead of a 1). The four dice are {1, 1, 1, 2} in any order: the 2 can sit in any of four positions, so 4 ways, about 0.31%.
  • Kept total 5. Two sets of dice qualify. {1, 1, 1, 3} can be arranged in 4 ways. {1, 1, 2, 2} can be arranged in 6 ways. Together 10 ways, about 0.77%.
  • Kept total 18. The three highest dice are all 6s, and the fourth die can show anything. If it shows a 6, there is 1 way. If it shows 1 to 5, the odd die can sit in 4 positions: 5 × 4 = 20 ways. Together 21 ways, about 1.62%.

Plain 3d6 reaches 3 and 18 in one way each out of 216, which is 0.46%. So drop-lowest makes a 3 rarer (0.08%) and an 18 more than three times as common (1.62%).

The full count

Kept total Ways (of 1,296) Percentage Plain 3d6 percentage
3 1 0.08% 0.46%
4 4 0.31% 1.39%
5 10 0.77% 2.78%
6 21 1.62% 4.63%
7 38 2.93% 6.94%
8 62 4.78% 9.72%
9 91 7.02% 11.57%
10 122 9.41% 12.50%
11 148 11.42% 12.50%
12 167 12.89% 11.57%
13 172 13.27% 9.72%
14 160 12.35% 6.94%
15 131 10.11% 4.63%
16 94 7.25% 2.78%
17 54 4.17% 1.39%
18 21 1.62% 0.46%

The ways sum to 1,296, so every ordered roll is counted once. The peak moves from the 10 and 11 of plain 3d6 (12.50% each) up to 13, which occurs on 172 of 1,296 rolls, 13.27%.

What the shift does to a character

The average kept total is about 12.24, against 10.5 for plain 3d6, a rise of about 1.7 points. The standard deviation falls from about 2.96 to about 2.85, because the results crowd around a higher centre (OpenStax — Mean or Expected Value and Standard Deviation gives the formulas used).

The change is easiest to see in the tails:

Event 4d6 drop lowest Plain 3d6
Kept total of 8 or less 136 of 1,296, about 10.5% 56 of 216, about 25.9%
Kept total of 15 or more 300 of 1,296, about 23.1% 20 of 216, about 9.3%
Kept total of 16 or more 169 of 1,296, about 13.0% 10 of 216, about 4.6%

Take a table of five players who each generate six scores: thirty scores. At the plain 3d6 rate you would expect about eight of them to be 8 or less. At the drop-lowest rate you would expect about three. That is the arithmetic behind the common remark that the method “feels kinder”: the weak score is much rarer, and the strong score is more than twice as common.

The rule decides the table, not the die

Every die in the count is assumed fair, each face equally likely; the table above follows from the rule about which dice count, not from anything odd about the dice. Change the rule and you get another table from the same dice. Keep the lowest three instead of the highest three and the whole picture mirrors. Roll five dice and keep three, and the high end grows again.

If you are designing a character-generation method, you are choosing which of the possible outcomes to keep and how to add them. Counting the orderings, as above, shows what the choice does before anyone rolls.

Check it yourself

Write out four columns of 1 to 6 and walk through the combinations for any one total, as in the hand counts above. For the full table, a short program that loops over all 1,296 ordered rolls, subtracts the smallest die from the sum and tallies the results will print the same 16 rows. If your tally differs from this table, the usual cause is dropping the highest die instead of the lowest, or counting unordered sets instead of ordered rolls.

Method

The counts come from a script that lists every ordered roll of four dice (1,296) and of three dice (216), computes the kept total and tallies it. The standard deviation and the tail figures come from the same tallies. The rule wording was read on 2026-10-31 from the free-rules page listed below.

Sources

Written for: a player who has been told “4d6 drop the lowest” is generous and wants to see how generous, and where.


Sources